12 Comments
User's avatar
Alyse Mason's avatar

So good, as always. And this line, above all: “ There is pretty much no better and more sustainable political arrangement for American big business than a (White) Left that dictates consumer culture and a (White) Right that controls politics. ”

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Thanks Alyse! I actually think that realization helps me have a little bit more grace with myself and others trying to do something different-- of course we're bad at this: Literally all the money in the world is invested in keeping things the way they are!

Expand full comment
Courtney Martin's avatar

Agreed. Brilliant.

Expand full comment
Courtney Martin's avatar

Dude, you are ready to teach a movement history course and I want to take it please! Could this be a Barnraisers elective?

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

The problem with studying movement history is you learn that 90% of movements are VERY, VERY BORING MEETINGS featuring a lot of names that are hard to remember.

Expand full comment
Ava's avatar

Garrett! This is so good, all of it, all the way down to the Bourdieu footnote!

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Nothing says "oof, time to wrap it up" quite like the moment that I'm adding in a Bourdieu footnote

Expand full comment
Maureen's avatar

Nailed it. I have one of those signs too (didn't want to feel left out) even though buying it made me feel like Mandy Moore here: https://giphy.com/gifs/mic-comedies-women-in-movies-QP2Tn47BucHjq

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

UNDERUSED GIF!!! That made me laugh out loud. And though I don't have that particular sign you better believe that I have a pair of virtue signalling signs just looking great in my front lawn as well.

Expand full comment
Antonia Malchik's avatar

Thank you for both these posts, Garrett. It’s a really hard question to find the shape of and I appreciate you helping the rest of us understand it!

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Oh thanks Nia! That's exactly how I feel when I read your writing about spaces (private property, roads, etc.).

Expand full comment
Antonia Malchik's avatar

That’s a big compliment, thank you!

Expand full comment