32 Comments
User's avatar
Kate Tyson's avatar

If nothing else, this just felt like...a rare sliver of sanity? Like, maybe people *can* practice discernment in the face of very retro, blatant Islamophobia ("I know! Let's photoshop his beard!") and that maybe, just maybe, corrupt sex pests shouldn't hold elected office (I mean, politics is rife with them, but just this once...).

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

As I typed that part of the essay, I was like "am I overstepping here or is it really true that the pundits that be have tried to convince us that there's no use in trying to keep sex pests from getting to do whatever they want, whenever they want it?" And it's absolutely insane but that's exactly what's happened!

Expand full comment
Kate Tyson's avatar

Yes! As if we aren't being gaslit enough...fucking Cuomo as a viable candidate for anything other than crawling in a dark hole somewhere to leave us all be.

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Wait when is the election for crawling in a dark hole somewhere because I'm, like, not NOT interested

Expand full comment
Kate Tyson's avatar

My neighbor and I walk our dogs together frequently and have an ongoing debate, that I feel you might be able to weight in on: should the entirety of Republican leadership be sent together to one lone, melting iceburg in the Antarctic surrounded by hungry polar bears...or each get their own lonely, isolated iceburg all by themselves (also surrounded by hungry polar bears)?

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Really important question. You know what, I am too much of a believer in the healing power of community, even for those who've strayed farthest from the light so let's give them a chance to figure it out together (but make sure the polar bears are super hungry-- stakes!)

Expand full comment
Kate Tyson's avatar

Most earnest person on the internet!!! <3

Expand full comment
Jane's avatar

Cuomo had billionaire dark money donors (and Michael Bloomberg’s chunky funding.)

Zohran had 50,000 + volunteers! People power is a stronger currency than dark money!

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

It's always true! And it's worth paying attention to which candidates are able to attract 50,000 volunteers and why people are so beautifully fired up!

Expand full comment
Ledeej's avatar

As a fellow non-New Yorker “ millennial socialist who pay too much attention to politics,” I feel this deeply! I can’t get enough of the joy of this campaign!

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

We're out here!

Expand full comment
Communion Co.'s avatar

I'm not crying you're crying...

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

That's another great thing about hot earnestness summer! cry away!

Expand full comment
Nathaniel's avatar

Right with you on this one, Garrett.

I was very discouraged by the attempts of the party machine to denigrate and sideline the Mamdani campaign. It was the same story we’ve heard so many times. The subtle whispers of Islamophobia and antisemitism along with the overt statements of “he’s too left leaning. The general electorate will never go for it”.

Well, in this one instance, the people rose up and tossed that out the window!

Early reporting says 60% of voters aged 18-34 voted for Mamdani and it appears that he led among male voters.

Maybe, perhaps, when you give people a candidate who talks about what they care about and seems to genuinely want to make their lives better, they enthusiastically support said candidate. Something for the powers that be to mull over.

The media tends to over-emphasize the New York Mayors race-for basically the same reasons that sports media over-emphasizes the Yankees, but I’ll play along this time. This was a super awesome election to watch unfold.

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Could not agree more, Nathaniel. People want to feel something!!!

Expand full comment
Emily's avatar

What feels so inspiring to me is that in the era of personality politics, where fealty to the leader is paramount was so soundly rejected. There are opposition politicians who are truly terrified, demanding Mamdani's denaturalization, but the victory isn't that of one man - it is the victory of 40,000 volunteers and tens of thousands of voters who were told they had agency to reject the status quo and found exercising that agency to be liberating. If culitivating insecurity in the population is how they've been controlled for decades, imagine what could happen if that population were made aware that they can choose not to be afraid, not to be cynical and that they don't have to have money or an elite status to exercise that choice.

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Emily, this is IT! This is why I'll never shut up about how the future we want will only be built by the radical act of saying to our neighbors "they don't want us to hope, they don't want us to trust, they don't want us to build together... but let's do it anyway!!"

Expand full comment
Amara Lynch's avatar

Loved so much about this piece and especially this:

There’s such freedom in earnestness, you all. When we see it in the wild, we might scoff at first, but eventually we too are tempted to let our guard down. If another human being can present like that—so nakedly, so guilelessly— perhaps we too can drop the icy front. No matter how much we pretend not to, we all dream, deep down, of a hot earnestness summer. What’s cooler than being cool? Hosting a potluck

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

I'm on a personal mission to shout down the myth that pretending not to care makes you cool.

Expand full comment
David Simpson's avatar

Such great news.

To keep the momentum going - and whenever you start to lose hope - crank up Stand - by Sly & The Family Stone - and read the lyrics. It couldn't be more spot-on and uplifting.

Expand full comment
K Salois's avatar

Ahhh that makes me a little teary. Can you believe that so many people felt that willing to be publicly ethical and optimist? Together? In person? And so many of them are still around and just…don’t, anymore?

Expand full comment
Lauren's avatar

GARRETT. 🥰

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

I'm so happy for you all!!!!

Expand full comment
Audrey Holst's avatar

I'm totally with you. I felt the joy and enthusiasm during this campaign and I cried when I saw how the votes poured in for him.

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Me too!

Expand full comment
Siena Chrisman's avatar

This New Yorker co-signs this whole piece! I got involved in the campaign in February-ish, first after seeing a couple of his videos where he’s just so smiling and enthusiastic, in those post 1/20 days I needed that kind of energy like oxygen. Then I went to his canvass kickoff in Brooklyn on a day that was about 25° and like 400 people were there! Clearly something was happening. I started canvassing in April and it was so fun to talk to my neighbors about a positive vision for the city. I stayed involved because it’s been the one thing that’s brought me real joy in these last few months- the community, the vision, Zohran’s infectious energy. You’re right on with this.

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Siena, THANK YOU TO YOU AND ALL YOUR NEIGHBORS! Canvassing in the cold! Canvassing in the heat! Canvassing (I'm sure) on those canvassing days when everybody seemed grumpy and didn't want to talk!! I'm so happy for you all, but I'm also hoping you see how much hope you've already spread across the country!

Expand full comment
K Salois's avatar

Yes to everything here, Garrett! And also yes to the way you somehow made Mamdani’s campaign feel like a montage from The Muppet Show.

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Which is why I love it so much! I've very much come to terms with the fact that my aethetic is "Muppet Show Montage!"

Expand full comment
David Simpson's avatar

Day to celebrate! BTW - if (rather when) you start to feel down, crank this one up full volume - and read the lyrics! https://open.spotify.com/track/68DqLs1hv7zI08EBvu53wV?si=fMSFeE-aQbCTyrqEtKH_og&context=spotify%3Aalbum%3A7iwS1r6JHYJe9xpPjzmWqD

Expand full comment
Garrett Bucks's avatar

Yes!!!

Expand full comment
Lane Anderson's avatar

New York Groove!! This is my fav NYC song--as a New Yorker, I approve :)

Expand full comment